Deciding when to begin receiving Old Age Security benefits
The Old Age Security (OAS) program is one of the two major federal benefit programs available to older Canadians – the other being the Canada Pension Plan (CPP). While both programs provide taxable monthly payments to Canadians, there are significant differences between the two.
The Canada Pension Plan is a contributory system, with Canadians contributing a percentage of income earned during their working years, and with the amount of benefits receivable based on the amount of contributions made. By contrast, OAS benefits are paid out of general government revenues, with no requirement that recipients pay into the plan.
The amount of the monthly OAS benefit is a fixed amount which is payable to anyone who has been resident in Canada for at least 40 years after the age of 18. (Reduced benefits are payable to those whose period of Canadian residence after the age of 18 is between 10 and 40 years.)
For the fourth quarter of 2024 (October to December), the maximum monthly benefit for recipients under the age of 75 is $728., while benefit recipients aged 75 and older can receive up to $800. per month. The other difference between the OAS and CPP programs is that eligible Canadians can begin to receive a CPP retirement benefit at age 60, but OAS benefits can start only once an individual turns 65. Formerly, OAS benefits were automatically paid to eligible recipients once they reached that age.
Now, however, Canadians who are eligible to receive OAS benefits are able to defer receipt of those benefits for up to five years, to when they turn 70 years of age. For each month that an individual Canadian defers receipt of those benefits, the amount of benefit eventually received increases by 0.6%. The longer the period of deferral, the greater the amount of monthly benefit eventually received. Where receipt of OAS benefits is deferred for a full 5 years, until age 70, the monthly benefit received is increased by 36%.
It can, however, be difficult to determine, on an individual basis, whether and to what extent it would make sense to defer receipt of OAS benefits. Some of the difficulty in deciding whether to defer – and for how long – lies in the fact there are no hard and fast rules, and the decision is very much an individual one. Fortunately, however, there are a number of factors which each individual can consider when making that decision.
The first such factor is how much total income will be required, at the age of 65, to finance current needs. It’s also necessary to determine what other sources of income (employment income from full- or part-time work, Canada Pension Plan retirement benefits, employer-sponsored pension plan benefits, annuity payments, and withdrawals from registered retirement savings plans (RRSPs) and registered retirement income fund (RRIFs)) are available to meet those needs, both currently and in the future, and when receipt of those income amounts can or will commence or cease. Once income needs and the sources and possible timing of each is clear, it’s necessary to consider the income tax implications of the structuring and timing of those sources of income.
The tax rate payable on retirement income (as with all income) increases as income rises and, in addition, the availability of a number of federal tax credits and benefits is eroded at higher incomes. The ultimate goal, as it is at any age, is to ensure sufficient income to finance a comfortable lifestyle while at the same time minimizing both the tax bite and the potential loss of tax credits and benefits.
In making those calculations, the following income tax thresholds and benefit cut-off figures are a starting point.
- Income in the first federal tax bracket is taxed at 15%, while income in the second bracket is taxed at 20.5%. For 2024, that second income tax bracket begins when taxable income reaches $55,867.
- The Canadian tax system provides (for 2024) a non-refundable tax credit of $8,790 for taxpayers who are age 65 or older at the end of the tax year. The amount of that credit is reduced once the taxpayer’s net income for the year exceeds $44,325.
- Individuals can receive a GST/HST refundable tax credit, which is paid quarterly. For 2024, the full credit is payable to individual taxpayers whose family net income is less than $44,324.
- Taxpayers who receive Old Age Security benefits and have income over a specified amount are required to repay a portion of those benefits through a mechanism known as the “OAS recovery tax” or clawback. Taxpayers whose net income for 2024 is more than $90,997 will have a portion of their future OAS benefits “clawed back.”
What other sources of income are currently available?
More and more, Canadians are not automatically leaving the workforce at the traditional retirement age of 65. Those who continue to work at paid employment and whose employment income is sufficient to finance their chosen lifestyle may well prefer to defer receipt of OAS. Similarly, a taxpayer who begins receiving benefits from an employer’s pension plan when they turn 65 may be able to postpone receipt of OAS benefits.
Is the taxpayer eligible for Canada Pension Plan retirement benefits, and at what age will those benefits commence?
Nearly all Canadians who were employed or self-employed after the age of 18 paid into the Canada Pension Plan and are eligible to receive CPP retirement benefits. While such retirement benefits can be received as early as age 60, receipt can also be deferred and received any time up to the age of 70. As is the case with OAS benefits, CPP retirement benefits increase with each month that receipt of those benefits is deferred. Taxpayers who are eligible for both OAS and CPP will need to consider the impact of accelerating or deferring the receipt of each benefit in structuring retirement income.
Does the taxpayer have private retirement savings through an RRSP?
Receipt of a monthly pension from an employer-sponsored pension plan is no longer the reality for the majority of Canadian retirees; such retirees have generally saved for their retirement through a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP). While taxpayers can choose to withdraw amounts from such plans at any age, they are required to collapse their RRSPs by the end of the year in which they turn 71 and to begin receiving income from those savings.
There are a number of options available for structuring that income but, whatever the option chosen (usually converting the RRSP into a registered retirement income fund (RRIF) or purchasing an annuity), it will mean that the taxpayer will begin receiving taxable income amounts from those RRSP funds in each year after they turn 71.
Taxpayers who have significant retirement savings in RRSPs should, in determining when to begin receiving OAS benefits, consider the tax impact that receipt of that additional taxable income amount from their RRSP will have in every future year.
The ability to defer receipt of OAS benefits does provide Canadians with more flexibility when it comes to structuring retirement income. The price of that flexibility is increased complexity, particularly where, as is the case for most retirees, multiple sources of income and the timing of each of those income sources must be considered, and none can be considered in isolation from the others.
Individuals who are undertaking that decision-making process will find some assistance on the Service Canada website. That website provides a very helpful Retirement Income Calculator, which, based on information input by the user, will calculate the amount of OAS which would be payable at different ages.
The calculator will also determine, based on current RRSP savings, the monthly income amount which those RRSP funds will provide during retirement. To use the calculator, it is necessary to know the amount of Canada Pension Plan benefit which will be received. Taxpayers who are registered for online access to My Service Canada Account can find that information there; those who are not can obtain that figure by calling Service Canada at 1-800 277-9914. The Retirement Income Calculator can be found at https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cpp/retirement-income-calculator.html.
The information presented is only of a general nature, may omit many details and special rules, is current only as of its published date, and accordingly cannot be regarded as legal or tax advice. Please contact our office for more information on this subject and how it pertains to your specific tax or financial situation